CLAIRE COLEMAN asks… why are beauty companies infantilising grown women?

One of many highlights of the sweetness calendar for make-up obsessives is the revealing of the Estee Lauder restricted version compacts. 

The model started producing these lovely, coveted, one-off designs in 1967 and annually the themed assortment is snapped up by followers who pore over their beautiful particulars. Earlier themes have included indicators of the zodiac, fortunate charms and aquatic creatures. 

This 12 months it is, er, Disney princesses, with every ornately embellished compact, costing between £200 and £350, representing scenes from movies resembling The Little Mermaid, The Princess And The Frog, and Magnificence And The Beast. 

In case you’re greatly surprised that such a classy product ought to have gone down such a infantile route, you should not be. This form of factor seems to have turn into the sweetness trade’s stock-in-trade. 

Estee Lauder has released a range of Disney compacts in reference to films including The Little Mermaid (pictured) which costs £350

The company also included a Sleeping Beauty compact (pictured) for £200

Estee Lauder has launched a spread of Disney compacts in reference to movies together with The Little Mermaid (left), which prices £350, and Sleeping Magnificence (proper), for £200

The use of childlike designs, such as Estee Lauder's Beauty and The Beast collection (pictured), has prompted questions for beauty companies about their motivations

The usage of childlike designs, resembling Estee Lauder’s Magnificence and The Beast assortment (pictured), has prompted questions for magnificence corporations about their motivations

This 12 months alone has seen MAC, which has created merchandise in partnership with highly effective girls together with Rihanna, Linda Evangelista and Mariah Carey, collaborating with Barbie; Italian model Kiko launching its Marvel Girl line; Barry M producing a Harry Potter make-up vary; and London-based Ciate revealing its Miss Piggy eyeshadows, lipsticks, blushers and extra. 

So are these cutesy collections merely interesting to our sense of nostalgia? Or is one thing extra sinister occurring? 

‘One of many methods wherein the sweetness trade sells merchandise to girls is by making them really feel they don’t seem to be ok,’ says psychologist Dr Martina Paglia, who has labored with younger individuals and girls with physique dysmorphia. 

‘And one of many ways in which you make a lady really feel that she’s not ok is by making her really feel that she is not younger sufficient. In our society, youth is equated with magnificence.’ 

She suggests the rationale why these characters from childhood are marketed to grown girls is as a result of there is a subliminal affiliation: in case you’re nonetheless enjoying with dolls or watching cartoons, you’ll be able to’t presumably be previous, so you could nonetheless be youthful and consequently lovely. 

‘They’re pushing you to establish your self with somebody youthful as a result of, by implication, it’ll make you seem extra engaging,’ she says. 

MAC too has also reverted to using Barbie in its advertising to women (pictured) in the hope of boosting its sales

MAC too has additionally reverted to utilizing Barbie in its promoting to girls (pictured) within the hope of boosting its gross sales

This helps to clarify why so many magnificence merchandise seem like they belong within the nursery, relatively than the lavatory. Revolution and GlamGlow are amongst many skincare manufacturers that promote glitter face masks. 

And search the time period ‘unicorn’ on on-line magnificence retailer lookfantastic. com and you will find greater than 30 totally different merchandise, even if the location sells to grown girls, and neither glitter nor unicorns have any useful position in magnificence. 

Nonetheless, in response to some within the trade, we’re taking all of it too severely; magnificence is supposed to be enjoyable and lighthearted, experimental and inventive, and we must always cease being so uptight. 

An Estee Lauder spokesperson mentioned: ‘Estee Lauder’s restricted version collaboration with Disney was designed to evoke nostalgia and rejoice iconic tales of energy, love and friendship, highlighting the princesses and moments from these tales which have made them beloved by generations.’ 

London-based Ciate's latest range was emblazoned with Miss Piggy's'love of colour and sparkle' (pictured)

London-based Ciate’s newest vary was emblazoned with Miss Piggy’s ‘love of color and sparkle’ (pictured)

MAC mentioned: ‘MAC is a model reflective of the cultural zeitgeist and serves as an entry level in magnificence for popular culture, artwork, music and trend icons. Popular culture’s iconic animated characters are an ideal match for magnificence as they elicit nostalgia and create a collectable second for followers.

‘Once you have a look at our previous collaborations with animated characters, all of them embody MAC’s core ethos of self-­confidence and individuality — from Barbie to Princess Jasmine in Disney’s reside motion film Aladdin to the Troll Dolls.’ 

Ciate founder Charlotte Knight argues that its core buyer, aged 25 to 45, ‘involves us for high quality product that feels inventive and playful’ and its latest vary imbued with Miss Piggy’s ‘love of color and sparkle…embodies a message of confidence and self-love’. 

The issue is that while you use cartoon characters to promote merchandise to girls, you are additionally attracting a really dif­ferent client. Lecturers have lengthy argued that the flip facet of infantilising girls is sexualising women, and getting very younger youngsters i­nterested in make-up is a technique they are often sexualised. 

Italian brand Kiko also recently launched its own Wonder Woman line (pictured)

It even included themed make-up bags (pictured)

Italian model Kiko additionally just lately launched its personal Marvel Girl line (merchandise pictured)

Collections such as the Harry Potter/Barry M range (pictured), launched this month on the Harry Potter shop, could be accused of targeting children

Collections such because the Harry Potter/Barry M vary (pictured), launched this month on the Harry Potter store, might be accused of concentrating on youngsters

Dr Paglia provides: ‘In case you use characters which might be engaging to youngsters to promote make-up to adults, you’ll be able to’t assist however get youngsters focused on magnificence and what they seem like, at a far youthful age than they may in any other case be.’ And it is true. 

I do not need Estee Lauder or MAC or Kiko to be on my eight-year-old niece’s radar, but when I stroll via a division retailer along with her and she or he spots unicorns on a make-up stand, she’s basically being groomed by the beauty giants. This could be an unintended consequence, however you can argue it is the sweetness trade’s means of stealth advertising and marketing to youngsters, luring them in at an ever youthful age. 

Manufacturers would possibly declare that the positioning and pricing of those merchandise imply they don’t seem to be concentrating on youngsters. However that argument falls aside while you have a look at collections such because the Harry Potter/Barry M vary, launched this month on the Harry Potter store. 

You may choose up Luna Love-good nail polishes, eyeshadows and lip glosses all priced at £7.95 or much less, or present your allegiance to the varsity homes Slytherin, Gryffindor, Hufflepuff or Ravenclaw with compact mirrors (£7.95), polish (£5.95) and nail information (£3.95). It is a part of a miserable development — final 12 months John Lewis and MAC promoted a ‘back-to-school mini masterclass’ on make-up for youngsters (cancelled after a backlash), whereas the Woman-guiding Women’ Attitudes Survey this 12 months discovered that eight out of ten women aged 11 to 21 have thought of altering their seems to be. 

Whereas the commonest causes have been the hope it could enhance their confidence (55 per cent) and make them really feel higher about themselves (54 per cent), a 3rd would do it to really feel extra accepted, suggesting that the sweetness trade goes to have a prepared provide of shoppers within the technology to return. 

And whereas we’re seeing grooming merchandise for males booming, the truth that it is women and girls, not boys and males, that we’re speaking about right here isn’t any coincidence. 

Sam Farmer, who began his self-titled skincare model for younger individuals as a result of he did not just like the gendered messages that the private care market despatched to youngsters, factors out that male customers aren’t topic to the identical type of nostalgia advertising and marketing. ‘You do not see Bulldog doing a restricted version Superman razor,’ he says. 

‘Are you able to think about Gillette or Nivea making an attempt to promote skincare to males utilizing Kermit the Frog?’ That, for me, is what’s on the coronary heart of all this. Girls are anticipated to look good and take an curiosity of their look however, paradoxically, are ridiculed by society for suggesting that make-up and skincare are subjects which might be worthy of curiosity or dialogue. 

Girls, and the sweetness i­ndustry, already face a battle to be taken severely, so infantilising girls by promoting merchandise utilizing cartoons and toys does actual harm. It reinforces the view that every one of these items is foolish, frivolous and indulgent. 

And, whether or not the manufacturers admit it or not, it permits cosmetics to sexualise younger women. Magnificence might be therapeutic, lifeaffirming and empowering, however this cynical, infantilising strategy does not solely undermine girls, it undermines your complete trade.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top