At present I’ve swatches and a evaluation of the Colourpop Blotted Lip and a comparability to the Glossier Era Gs. The Glossier Era G Lipsticks had been launched in 2016 to the delight of many individuals trying to find a low-fuss sheer matte lipstick. I reviewed two shades on the weblog, Cake and Leo earlier than on the weblog.
Virtually a yr later, Colourpop launched their Blotted Lip as a part of a collaboration with Alexis Ren. The Blotted Lip was described as offering a sheer matte end that is buildable and light-weight and given how a lot I favored the Era Gs (not less than in Cake), I assumed I might get the Blotted Lip and examine the 2 (and it seems they share fairly a couple of similarities) and see if it may very well be thought of a dupe of each other.
Proceed studying to listen to my ideas, learn the comparability, and see swatches!
Product Description Comparability
- Sheer matte lipstick that creates the right popsicle pout! System is light-weight, matte and buildable for gentle to medium protection.
- Era G is a brand new form of lip colour that gives the impression and end of just-blotted lipstick, with out the blot. We’ve created a brief listing of the six most necessary shades, with dialed-down pigment hundreds for an informal look: Zip, Leo, Crush, and Jam, together with the tremendous refined Cake and Like, which give some oomph to lighter lip tones. They’re lipsticks that adapt to you, not the opposite approach round, in order that they’ll seem a bit completely different on everybody as your pure lip colour exhibits via. The impact? Subtle, matte goodness—simply swipe it on.
The Colourpop Blotted Lips are $5.00 for 1 gram of product whereas the Glossier Era G are $18.00 for two grams of product. I am stunned at how a lot product the Blotted Lips are trigger it has the identical casing because the Era G, solely a bit longer. Because it goes by weight, maybe it is simply much less dense?
Coloration Vary Comparability
There are six colours within the Era G vary whereas there are eight colours within the Blotted Lip Vary. There are two extra refined shades within the Era G vary whereas all of the Blotted Lip seem to have an analogous stage of pigmentation.
Listed below are the Blotted Lips. Left to proper: Drip, Ice Dice, and Sucker.
Listed below are the Era Gs. Left to proper: Cake and Leo.
Each lip merchandise are packaged in a slimline white tube. The Blotted Lip has a matte end whereas the Era G has a shiny end. The tube for the Blotted Lip is a bit longer than the Era Gs. The Era G is all white on the within whereas the liner for the Blotted Lips are colour coordinated.
The Era Gs are infamous for having a slightly flimsy cap, actually each of my tubes have cracked caps. Although I have not owned the Blotted Lips lengthy sufficient to know whether or not they’ll crack or not, it does really feel just like the cap is a bit sturdier.
The Glossier Era Gs tout having a “dialed down pigment load” for a lot of the shades (Leo included) whereas additionally describing Cake and Like as being “tremendous refined”. Due to this, Cake takes not less than 4 to 5 swipes to get a light-weight end whereas it is two to 4 for a sheer end with Leo.
The Colourpop Blotted Lips as compared give gentle protection from the get go and construct as much as a medium protection with a number of swipes.
Hopefully these arm swatches will show you how to see the distinction. From left to proper, Colourpop Drip, Ice Dice, Sucker, Glossier Cake and Leo.
Each do really feel agency within the tubes however the Era Gs really feel extra emollient than the Blotted Lip. The Era Gs glide a lot simpler on the lips, among the Blotted Lips tug on the lips after I apply them although it is improved if I pair it with a balm. I do really feel like each formulation are neither drying or hydrating.
The Blotted Lip in Drip and Sucker have nearer to a semi-matte end whereas Ice Dice has a extra flat matte end and feels firmer/tugs extra on the lips. The Era Gs in Cake and Leo have a pure matte end, not as flat matte because the Blotted Lips. The pure matte end makes the Era G’s extra comfy to put on in comparison with the Blotted Lips. Nevertheless, you may make the Blotted Lips by making use of one layer of Blotted Lip, a layer of lip balm, and a layer of Blotted Lip.
Put on time for the Era Gs are about two to 4 hours, whereas a great put on time for the Blotted Lip is about three to 4 hours however you may make it final 5 to 6 hours. By good put on time, I imply the lips can look dry with the Blotted Lip after three or 4 hours as a result of it is not as creamy/extra matte.
Do I think about these a dupe? Not 100% however you may actually get an analogous impact with the Blotted Lips.
All these swatches had been taken in pure daylight with no flash.
Drip is described as a “heat rosey mauve”. My favourite of the three Blotted Lips and it is excellent to put on to work.
Ice Dice is described as a “cool-toned berry”. It is fairly a pink however I did not like this as a lot as a result of it felt fairly onerous within the tube and tugged greater than the others when making use of.
Sucker is described as a “delicate coral”. It’s brilliant for on a regular basis put on for me however I feel this might be excellent throughout the transition time between spring and summer season.
Cake is described as a “refined peachy nude”. My favourite of the Era Gs, yeah it does not seem like a lot however it’s really easy to use and I by no means have to fret about it trying messy. It provides only a good trace of colour.
Leo is described as a “heat cocoa brown”. I choose carrying this extra sheerly as a result of I feel it will possibly look too brown when constructed up. You’ll be able to actually construct this to look a smidge extra pigmented.
This specific comparability made me slightly , there’s quite a lot of overlap between the 2 formulation. I did not embrace the colorants for the Glossier ingredient lists since every shade has completely different ones however the base formulation is identical.
- Ethylhexyl Stearate, Polyethylene, Cyclopentasiloxane, Cetyl PEG/PPG-10/1 Dimethicone, C10-18 Triglycerides, Isohexadecane, C30-45 Alkyl Cetearyl Dimethicone Crosspolymer, BHT,
- Ethylhexyl Stearate, Polyethylene, Cyclopentasiloxane, Cetyl PEG/PPG-10/1 Dimethicone, C10-18 Triglycerides, Isohexadecane Dimethicone/Vinyl Dimethicone Crosspolymer, C30-45 Alkyl Cetearyl Dimethicone Crosspolymer, PEG/PPG-20/23 Dimethicone, Phenoxyethanol, Punica Granatum Extract, Silica, Aluminum Dimyristate, Triethoxycaprylylsilane, Isoceteth-10, Disodium Stearoyl Glutamate, Cyclotetrasiloxane, Laureth-4, Carthamus Tinctorius (Safflower) Seed Oil, Agave Tequilana Leaf Extract, Tocopheryl Acetate, BHT.
The primary seven components for each merchandise are listed in the identical order, although clearly that does not imply they’re in the identical ratios. I feel the additional components utilized by Glossier present a extra emollient really feel and the higher glide on the lips.
There are similarities within the components, packaging, put on time, and impact in your lips. The variations are within the pigmentation, end, colour vary, consolation on the lips, and pricing. The query comes down as to if you desire a lip colour with a greater really feel and lighter protection that you do not thoughts build up or the value of (Glossier) or if you’d like much more versatility by having a product you may put on sheerly or have extra protection from at a cheap worth (Colourpop) that is not as simple to glide on.
For me, I actually love the Era G in Cake and the way it seems to be on me and sadly there’s not an analogous colour within the Blotted Lip formulation in order that’s a colour I plan on repurchasing. When you like brighter lip colours with a flexible end, I say check out the Blotted Lip since there is a ton of colours and you will get an analogous impact to the brighter shades from the Era Gs for those who do not thoughts giving up among the consolation. Nevertheless, given the truth that you may get three of the Colourpop Blotted Lips for the value of 1 Glossier Era G, I do not suppose you will thoughts pairing it with a lip balm to enhance the consolation stage.
I hope you loved this comparability publish between the Colourpop Blotted Lip and the Glossier Era Gs. If that is your first Colourpop order, you may obtain $5.00 off utilizing my referral hyperlink and I get $5.00. If that is your first Glossier order, you may obtain 10% off utilizing my referral hyperlink and I get $10.
Are you a fan of sheer matte lipsticks?
Disclaimer: I bought each merchandise myself (I used affiliate credit score for the Glossier Era Gs). I used to be not compensated/paid for this publish. This publish does include affiliate hyperlinks, which offer me with referral credit score for those who use it to your buy. All opinions are my very own!