MAC Lip Pencil | Ulta Beauty

Product Critiques

Rated 4.6 out of 5 stars

549 Critiques

Stone is again?!?!?! THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU

I got here on the location right now to reorder a lipstick that had run low, and determined to examine my “Favorites” listing to see if there was something there that I wanted. And lo and behold an previous good friend reappeared – Stone lip pencil. I assumed I have to be seeing issues. However no, it is there. And it isn’t marked as a restricted version.

Because it was discontinued a number of years in the past, I’ve searched excessive and low for a alternative. However nothing was ever fairly proper. For the final yr I had to make use of an EYE LINER to attempt to copy the colour. Sure, an eye fixed liner. I turned determined.

This was the proper colour for me to line my lips. It magically appeared to make my lips appear fuller (most likely because it appears to virtually mimics a really mild shadow – thus giving the allusion of fuller lips). It additionally tones down brighter shades and turns pinks and nudes into colours that appear pure, wholesome and delightful. Some individuals could also be turned off as a result of it’s described as gray muted taupe. However it’s a actually pure wanting colour. Simply not as yellow or orange as most “pure” or “beige” liners are typically.

I ordered the utmost quantity that I used to be allowed with the biggest smile on my face. PLEASE, PLEASE NEVER DISCONTINUE THIS AGAIN.


I have been shopping for the MAC lip pencil in Stripdown for over ten years. It is the one product I exploit to line and fill in my lips. The colour intently matches my pure lip colour and each pencil I’ve bought by way of the years has by no means diversified in colour or consistency, its at all times been precisely the identical. I simply acquired an order of two Stripdown lip pencils and one thing has undoubtedly modified. The colour is completely different. It is extra of a matte mild brown and the consistency is terrible. It is delicate not agency. It is extra like a lipstick consistency. I am unable to use it to line my lips as a result of it smudges, is messy and the tip breaks off with very minimal strain. Each lip pencils I acquired are this identical new product.

Did I simply get a foul batch or has my favourite colour lip pencil actually modified? I am so upset.

Has anybody else skilled this downside?

The colour I have been searching for!


Katy from Orange County ca

I noticed Laura beverlin use this on IG to make her lips look greater, I did not assume the colour would swimsuit me since I’ve truthful pores and skin, nevertheless it’s superb!!! I really feel like it is a colour that will look good on everybody! I additionally paired it with Kylie’s liquid lip in “Koko” and it is verry fairly!

Too Dry


Jasmine from Illinois

This lip pencil was very dry and harsh on my lips. It damage to use and felt like I used to be scraping myself. There was not a lot colour pigmentation both, so it isn’t definitely worth the worth.

Lip liner


Penny from Delaware

I like the truth that it goes on easy, filled with moisture and it wears lengthy.

Pencil is so dry, it is not possible to make use of


Scarlett from Emerald Metropolis

I like Ruby Woo lipstick so I made a decision to strive the matching pencil. The pencil’s color is nice however the pencil is so dry that I’ve to scrape and scrape to get any color in any respect from the pencil to my lips. I’ve tried utilizing it with fully dry lips, freshly oiled lips, and every part in-between. I simply can’t get this color to really switch any color to my lips! It will definitely begins tearing the flesh of my lips, which is painful, and STILL THERE IS NO COLOUR TRANSFER! I’m past aggravated!!

i might not purchase this product once more


mary from lakewood, oh

I really feel like im ripping my lips off attempting to make use of this liner

must be creamier so it glides on

Ought to of taken it again


Carol from Michigan

This pencil may be very exhausting and dry. Thought Mac can be model pencil. Virtually hurts your lips to make use of it. Ought to of returned it.

Very pure lip liner


Khim from Indiana

Since I am presently residing lipstick free, I wished a pure wanting liner to nonetheless really feel pulled collectively. This lip pencil offers precisely that.

I like my Mac lip pencils


Janell from Choctaw, OK

I’ve used Mac pencils for years after attempting many manufacturers. Numerous colour decisions and lengthy lasting.

Value it


Can from Arizona

I am all a couple of low finish dupe however with lip liners, Mac lip liners are so completely different in consistency and high quality! I’ll splurge for these and simply tip them with my decrease finish dupes lol

I’ve olive pores and skin, mild berry coloured lips. This specific colour is a bit of too mild.

Favourite Impartial Lip Liner


Sooner Gal from Tulsa, OK

It is simply creamy sufficient and lengthy lasting. That is my second one to buy…

Actually like this colour!


Jimminicrkt from McKinney, TC

Purchased this lip liner in each Plum and Soar. I’ve solely tried out Plum to this point, nevertheless it’s simply going to turn out to be my new fave! I actually like how easily it goes on, no tugging (even on tremendous dry lips), and the endurance was nice!

half happy


Good nurse from Dallas

Purchased this together with a c-thru lip glass. Unable to deal with in retailer , salesperson rang buy and bagged. Received house to discover a squeeze tube of clear lip gloss. Bought the right merchandise on-line from one other retailer. Lip liner was wonderful as at all times.

I will not purchase this product once more, might be returning.


Teri from KY

The pencil is dry and colour does not go on because it seems in pencil. The primary one was too pink and the second was orange. I used to be attempting to purchase a pinkish brown or pinkish nude.



M from Tx

I bought this as a result of I am fairly positive I noticed Alexa Demi use it in a video, anyhow, the shade is so beautiful nevertheless it simply rubs off simply particularly in case you are making out. This man barely had lips nevertheless it nonetheless rubbed off ugh. The lip liner wasn’t the one disappointment I assume.

Good pair with Crimson Scare


Ok from Austin

A longtime lover of all thinks MAC and this liner is a good high quality product to put on alone or with a lipstick. I do not do liquid lippies and as a substitute, use the MAC prep and prime for lips with a liner for the proper lip. I bought the Cherry lip line to pair with Trixie Cosmetics Crimson Scare lipstick and it a fab match. Pulls very red-blue.

Nice pencil


Yogawoman from Hopedale, MA

Whirl is a good colour that goes with loads of lip colours

I might purchase this product once more


Heather from Yucaipa

I like Mac merchandise. Good shade



Sissy from Alexandria, La

This colour goes with nearly any lipstick

Adore it


Ruby from Charlotte.NC

Love the colour Is gorgeous and keep longer that I assumed

All time favourite lip liner


Viktoreyah from Portland

That is my all time favourite liner : so easy, plumps my lips . The colour is ideal it matches loads of completely different shades of lipsticks

Nice Pencils


delila from Ohio

They go on completely! In addition they final all day, undoubtedly going to purchase extra colours

Spice liner


Meesh from Va

Spice is the most effective liner shade ever for mild heat pores and skin tones. It’s so pigmented and matches any impartial lipstick. With different liners I fear about my lips dropping definition after consuming however this at all times stays on.

Nice lip pencils


KY Lady from Lexington, KY

I purchased Whirl and Soar throughout 21 Days of Magnificence. They’re each nice lip pencils! Soar is creamier and goes on a bit of simpler, however Whirl goes on simply after warmed up a bit of. Each are nice Fall colours! Neither colour bleeds and each keep on all day. I prefer to line my lips, then fill in my whole lip and throw on some clear gloss. I can use each as an on a regular basis lip pencil. Excited to strive different colours.

Love this lipliner


Scarlet from Riverside, CA

It really easy to make use of to line lips or fill your entire lips and colour is lengthy lasting.

Fairly colour


Ginormica M. from Ga.

Very fairly, yr spherical, colour. Not my first MAC lip pencil so I can say with certainty it should final a really very long time. Received it on sale. Nice purchase.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top